New York Cupcakes Home

Most of our flavors are available in Gluten Free. Contact store for specific details.

"All flavors are subject to availability and may not be available due to circumstance. Flavors are subject to change at any time. We suggest contacting the store in advance with any questions."

♥ Represents Filled Cupcakes

(SP) Represents Specialty Cupcakes

(C) Represents Catering (starting 2 dozen regular and 2 dozen mini cupcakes)

Classic Chocolate Vanilla

Chocolate Cake, vanilla buttercream, dark chocolate curls.

Birthday Cake

White Cake, chocolate or vanilla buttercream, rainbow sprinkles.

Banana Puddin Pie

White Cake. Nilla wafer cookie crust, vanilla puddin' filling, banana puddin' buttercream, Nilla wafer on top. ♥

Boston Cream Cutie Pie

White Cake, custard filling, fudge buttercream, dollop of buttercream. ♥

Broadway Banana Split

Banana Cake, fudge filling, strawberry-vanilla swirled buttercream, dipped in milk chocolate, maraschino cherry (nuts optional.) ♥ (C)

Candy Store Salted Caramel

Chocolate Cake, homemade salted caramel filling, caramel, buttercream dollop of fudge buttercream, pinch of sea salt. ♥

Chocolate Chocolate Decadence

Chocolate Cake, chocolate buttercream, dark chocolate curls.

Chocolate Chip

White chocolate chip cake, vanilla buttercream, chocolate chip topping.

Cookies & Cream

Chocolate or white cake, Oreo buttercream, dollop of whipped buttercream.

Coffee Shop Cupcakes (Mocha or Latte)

Chocolate or white cake (Mocha or Latte) coffee buttercream, chocolate covered espresso bean.

Triple Coconut

White or chocolate coconut cake, coconut buttercream, sweetened coconut flakes.(SP)

Cookie Dough Delight

Chocolate cake, cookie dough center, vanilla buttercream, fresh baked chocolate chip cookie crumbles. ♥ (SP)

Chocolate Swirled Banana Bread

Chocolate & Banana swirled cake, cream cheese frosting, chocolate sprinkles.(C)

Campfire S’mores

Chocolate Cake, baked marshmallow center, marshmallow buttercream, mini Hershey Bar. (SP)

Lemon Raspberry

Lemon cake, raspberry buttercream, candied flower.

Bewitching Brownie

Chocolate Cake, baked brownie batter, vanilla buttercream w/ fudge or chocolate buttercream w/caramel, baked brownie on top.(SP)

Honey Lavender

White cake infused with honey~Lavender, honey lavender buttercream!

The Hostess

Chocolate cake, cream filling, chocolate ganache.

Lemon-Lemon Love

Lemon cake, lemon buttercream.

Mint Chocolate Chip

Chocolate "chocolate" chip cake, mint buttercream, semi-sweet mini chocolate chips, mint candy.

Milk & Cookies

Milk & Cookies - White cake, chocolate cookie crust, chocolate cookie pieces, vanilla buttercream, chocolate cookie dust. (SP) (C)

New York Black & White

Marble cake, marble buttercream, white & milk chocolate candy stick.

New York Neapolitan (Summer only)

Chocolate Strawberry layer cake, vanilla buttercream, sprinkles, maraschino Cherry.

Oh My Blueberry Pie

White cake, blueberry pie filling, vanilla buttercream, pie crust topping. ♥

Miss MudPie

Chocolate cake, Oreo cookie crust, creamy caramel center, Oreo/Mocha buttercream, fudge drizzle, chocolate covered espresso bean.

Orange Creamsicle

White cake, cream filling, orange buttercream. ♥

French Toast & Maple Bacon

Cinnamon French toast cake, maple buttercream, candied maple baked bacon, brown sugar sprinkle. (SP)

Chocolate Peanut Butter "Cup"

Chocolate cake, peanut butter buttercream, mini peanut butter cup.

Frosted Sugar Cookie

White cake, pink buttercream, pink sugar sprinkles!

White Wedding Cake

White cake, white buttercream, white chocolate curls.

Chocolate Raspberry & Raspberry Vanilla

Chocolate or white cake, raspberry buttercream, chocolate sprinkles.

Red Velvet

Red velvet cake, whipped buttercream, red sugar sprinkles.

Saturday Morning Cinnamon Roll

Cinnamon strussel cake, vanilla bean cream cheese frosting, brown sugar sprinkle.

Sweet Vanilla Strawberry

White cake, strawberry buttercream, sprinkles.

Snicker Doodle Doo

Cinnamon cake, vanilla buttercream, cinnamon sugar sprinkles.

Chocolate Cherry & Cherry Vanilla 

Chocolate or white cake, cherry buttercream, Hershey's Kiss on chocolate, maraschino cherry on vanilla.

Strawberry Milkshake

Strawberry Cake, strawberry buttercream, pink sugar sprinkles.

Summer Strawberries & Cream

Strawberry cake, vanilla buttercream, sugar sprinkles, sugar flower.

Chocolate Butterscotch “Heath Bar” 

Snickers, Milky Way, Heath Bar, or Twix. (contact store for daily selection and description)

Fun Funfetti

Funfetti Cake, vanilla buttercream frosting, rainbow non-perils, gummy bears!

Vanilla Fudge Twirl

White cake, fudge ribbon, swirled vanilla bean & fudge buttercream, swirled Hershey Kiss.

Vanilla Bean Cream

White Cake, Madagascar vanilla bean buttercream. Red sugar flower.

Very Berry Lemonade (Summer only)

Lemon cake, strawberry filling, strawberry buttercream!♥





$4.00-$4.25...Seasonal & Special




(no discount on seasonal & specials)

Mini Cupcakes

$1.75 - Regular

$2.00 - Seasonal & Special

$21.00 - One Dozen

(no discount on seasonal & specials)

Gluten Free

$4.00 - Regular

$4.50 - Special or Filled

$45.00 - One Dozen

Cake Pops




Sugar Cookies


Additional labor charge may
apply on any custom cake pops, macarons, or sugar cookies order.

Custom Cakes

4" cake - $20.00 (2-3 slices)

6" cake - $40.00 (4-6 slices)

8" cake - $60.00 (8-12 slices)

10" cake - $75.00 (15-20 slices)

12" cake - $95.00 (20-30 slices)


Standard cake sizes and base pricing.
Additional charges may apply
based on added customization.
Additional sizes available.
Please contact store for
size and pricing details.

Special Orders

48 hours notice for all special orders.

72 hours notice for larger orders.

Weddings, Anniversaries,
Birthday Parties,
Business Meetings